Jamie Richardson posted: " Just over a week into 2022, and my definitely not a resolution plan to work through my Birthday and Christmas book stash is going well. I have just finished the first book on the list, Kindred by Rebecca Wragg Sykes, which was an excellent start to m"
Just over a week into 2022, and my definitely not a resolution plan to work through my Birthday and Christmas book stash is going well. I have just finished the first book on the list, Kindred by Rebecca Wragg Sykes, which was an excellent start to my post-Christmas reading.
Next on my list I think will be The Man in the High Castle which my wonderful wife bought for me. After hitting a couple of heavy non-fiction books in a row I am looking for some lighter fictional reading (even if it does include Nazis…)
Before I head into book 2, I should probably give you my review of Kindred, because this is a book you need to have on your own to be read pile!
Kindred, Neanderthal Life, Love, Death and Art
My rating:
I first heard about Kindred on The Rest is History podcast when they did an episode on Neanderthals and praised the book in the process. When family and friends asked me what I wanted as a present for Christmas, this book was at the top of the list and I was not disappointed.
Ambitiously covering both our modern understanding of Neanderthals, the lives they lived and their culture, as well as exploring the archeological history of their discovery and the way our modern prejudices have clouded interpretation of the finds, it is incredible Wragg Sykes managed to fit everything into under 400 pages. While I thought I knew a fair amount about Neanderthals, page after page told me I had barely scratched the surface.
As well as covering expected topics when thinking about prehistoric peoples (fossils and stone tools), Kindred also explores more tentative or speculative conclusions about Neanderthals including hints at culture, death customs and art. Wragg Sykes is careful to both hypothesise only as far as the data will allow and to offer the range of potential explanations for the data when multiple conclusions can be drawn. To produce an academically rigorous text which is also enjoyable by a lay audience is quite a skill.
What Ireally liked
Clearly well researched, the book gives a detailed exploration of everything we know about Neanderthals (and what we are still to understand) but delivered in a style which remained engaging throughout.
The book is wonderfully illustrated, from the artwork at the start of each chapter setting the scene, to the figures dotted throughout the text. While used sparingly and kept as simple line drawings, they are all the more impactful for it.
The chapter on genetics was a particular highlight, succinctly reminding me of the lingering genetic markers some of us still have of Neanderthal ancestors. The genetics of Humans, Neanderthals and other hominids is a complicated mess, yet Wragg Sykes has managed to write in a way which I think is approachable to the average reader.
And finally while the book is an exploration of the scientific understanding of Neanderthals, it does not shy away from the very real lessons which can be drawn about our own society and some of the pressing dangers we face today. Of course you cannot make direct comparisons between Neanderthals and our modern world, but important themes can be explored which are to a degree applicable to us and Wragg Sykes is not afraid of writing as much.
The less good bits
I only really have one gripe with this book; the epigraphs. Every chapter starts with a short piece of prose (which I assume Wragg Sykes wrote) and I could not see the point of them. If anything they distracted from the text which holds its own well enough. If (when) you do read Kindred, I'd suggest missing the epigraphs and get straight into the good stuff.
Summary
Kindred is a fantastic, readable, impressively detailed and clearly laid out exploration of all things Neanderthal. Whether you are an Neolithic novice or prehistoric professor, there is something for you in this book which will leave you in awe of both our ancient cousins as well as the incredible conclusions science can draw from just the smallest scraps of evidence.
I suspect every reader will take something different from Kindred. For me, I wonder if it is time to stop calling ourselves humans. There is no doubt Neanderthals were as much humans as we are. Perhaps it is time we consider ourselves Sapiens instead!
Have you read Kindred or got it on the TBR pile? What did you take from the book if you have read it? Let me know what you think in the comments below.
nemonemini posted: "The_Last_Revolution_Postcapitalist_ Futures_ver_x9FNL_9xa_1_7_22 Our short book is being vindicated by the rapid devolution of the American system: a recent book, The Next Civil War, predicts the collapse of the American system of government. It is a poin"
The_Last_Revolution_Postcapitalist_ Futures_ver_x9FNL_9xa_1_7_22 Our short book is being vindicated by the rapid devolution of the American system: a recent book, The Next Civil War, predicts the collapse of the American system of government. It is a point we have made many times in a slightly different conceptual framework: and the intent of our idea of The Last Revolution is, while not as such intended in that way, a response to the revolution from the right underway. All sort of discussions make assumptions about democracy and the liberal context. But that context is starting to fall apart. Trump's era triggered something that was already the case, and the results were surprising beyond expectation, to say the least. We have taken up the theme of the now rising chorus bemoaning the danger to democracy and pointed to the solution: the 'democracy' so-called needs to become a real democracy, which requires redefinition as socialist democracy,...
A recent book, The Next Civil War, The right has recognized that the system is in collapse, and it has a plan: violence and solidarity with treasonous far-right factions Stephen Marche Tue 4 Jan 2022 05.00 EST Nobody wants what's coming, so nobody wants to see what's coming. On the eve of the first civil war, the most intelligent, the most informed, the most dedicated people in the United States could not see it coming. Even when Confederate soldiers began their bombardment of Fort Sumter, nobody believed that conflict was inevitable. The north was so unprepared for the war they had no weapons.
nemonemini posted: "Postcapitalist Futures: The Last Revolution The_Last_Revolution_Postcapitalist_ Futures_ver_x8FNL_8xa_1_5_22 Decoding World History decoding-world-history-ed-1_6dcdx Descent of Man Revisited 9780984702909_Descent_of_Man_Revisited(3) Democratic_Market_Ne"
nemonemini posted: "Decoding World History ED 1_6dcdx Decoding World History (decodingworldhistory.com)is a presentation of the data for the so-called 'eonic effect' and the hidden process of historical 'evolution'. It can dispel the ideological muddle of curren"
Decoding World History (decodingworldhistory.com)is a presentation of the data for the so-called 'eonic effect' and the hidden process of historical 'evolution'. It can dispel the ideological muddle of current evolutionary pseudo-science and its reductionist scientism. Read more of this post